Confrontation Naming Aphasia Speech Therapy?
In addition the person with the speaking difficulty repeats or “names” words that are often stimulated from flash cards. The words are practiced with printed words, pictures, or both.
Confrontation Naming Aphasia Speech Therapy does not have a positive connotation. Within that term is a root word: to confront. Being confronted does not conjure up positive thoughts.
Being confronted is often unexpected. In addition it’s usually an uncomfortable experience.
What the dictionary says about ‘to confront’
The dictionary defines the word confront: to meet (someone) face to face with hostile or argumentative intent. It’s like being blamed for something we did not do, or were incapable of doing. Additionally, it’s not fun!
We’re taught the theory but rarely if ever the way to do the therapy
As a speech language pathology student, I could never get the gist of language therapy, because there was no expert there who knew how to do language therapy in a fun and easy way. The majority of the professors would frequently tell us the therapy methods would be covered “later in the course,” but that rarely, if ever happened. Therefore fun and easy methods of speech and language techniques for children who were not talking were never covered. Likewise this “We’ll get to that later phenomenon” also occurred for the adult populations with aphasia. . . We’re taught the theory, but the methods are often minimized or lacking.
What’s it like having to fend for yourself?
Therefore as a student I had to fend for myself. I found empty boxes and filled them with bathroom items, and kitchen utensils, and found photographs of people doing things. Specific picures of people in the professions, and food item were used. I then went about taking large flash cards and asking the patient: “Now what is this__________? or What is that______?” “Now say This is _______.” (Makes me sleepy even thinking about it!)
It’s no fun having frustration whether you are a therapist or client/patient
Patients with aphasia and children who do not talk often have difficulty with confrontational naming tasks. They frustrate therapists, caregivers, and anyone else in the process! Those wih aphasia or childhood speech and language delay often needs cues. They often struggle since the the task is too difficult and they are not at an approiate level to do tasks of immediate or short term memory. That process needs to be built slowly by a competent therapist who understands simple principles of speech and language stimulation.
Am I really doing this patient any good?
I would often scratch my head and wonder: “Am I really doing this person any good with confrontational therapy?”
Confrontation Naming Aphasia Speech Therapy
It’s dissapointing to realize you’re not doing any good for the patient
Sadly, my clients were not talking any better!
There must be a better way!
(I figured there must be something out there that would be better than what I was doing!)
My observations of what other therapists were doing
Through the years I had the opportunity to watch other speech language pathologists do therapy. It was surprising many had similar training, or lack of it. I watched many of them do the confrontational naming tasks. One can be very entrenched in a method without realizing that it has minimal efficacy in the real speaking world.
At last, Eureka!
With experience and great dissatisfaction with confrontational naming tasks and hand-out sheets I finally used (shhhhhh…don’t tell anyone) common sense and fun techniques.
Realistically I could stimulate speech and language while talking with the person, especially about interests (discourse), rather than boring and redundant tasks of identifying single word pictures that often had no functional use for normal, everyday conversation.
Trying to correct or improve speaking with confrontational techniques is just NOT FUN! (yawn) for anyone concerned! (It’s like doing oral motor exercises with no attention to speaking, or practicing the sounds of speech by themselves and not within words.) Believe me I know!
Confrontation Naming Aphasia Speech Therapy. What the research shows us
There is some research that addresses the use of confrontational naming in the speech pathology literature. There are some enlightened investigators who find that those with aphasia tend to speak more readily when they are spoken to in discourse (talking) in a way that stimulates interesting language that is at an appropriate level of difficulty. The results are much more complimentary in comparison to those who are asked to do confrontational naming tasks.
My 2 cents worth
To me Confrontation Naming Aphasia Speech Therapy is not stimulating speech and language and has nothing to do with talking or discourse. It is confrontational and typically sets up increased stress, anxiousness and frustration. Not only that but it also has a tendency to set up “performance anxiety,” in people who cannot and should not be confronted to recall when they have not had enough opportunity for repetition of the word or phrase. That is a very difficult task for those who have severe anomia and aphasia.
That’s how and why the Teaching of Talking was developed
The Teaching of Talking, an approach to speech and language stimulation is the result of over 40 years of my life’s work with children and adult neuro-patients and those who have difficulty speaking. It is a relaxed and fun way to stimulate speech in discourse or conversation. It gives the person with a speaking difficulty and their loved one or caregiver a better chance for speech recovery. It’s simple and the work is done at the individuals’ level of speaking. It can be at the single word level or longer.
If the person with the speaking difficulty can imitate or mimic words, phrases or sentences, they can be included in conversations with one or more people!
It is a way to get the person with the speaking difficulty talking, even if it is cued. One can be comical, serious or fun-loving in the approach.